Ritual Offerings Connecting Humans and Deities

Paul Kocot Nietupski
Close view of polychrome butter sculpture depicting blue-skinned deity seated before nimbus of flowers and mythological creatures

Vajradhara, torma butter sculpture; Labrang Monastery, Amdo region, eastern Tibet (Gansu Province, China); 2006; flour, butter, natural pigments; height of figure approx. 12 in. (30.5 cm); photograph by Sandar Aung

Tormas

Labrang Monastery, Amdo region, eastern Tibet (Gansu Province, China) 2006–2014

Vajradhara, torma butter sculpture; Labrang Monastery, Amdo region, eastern Tibet (Gansu Province, China); 2006; flour, butter, natural pigments; height of figure approx. 12 in. (30.5 cm); photograph by Sandar Aung

Summary

Effigies known as torma and usually made of flour and butter—staples in the Himalayan diet—are used as enticing offerings to deities. Tormas can be empowered symbols of buddhas or receptacles of negative forces to be exorcized in rituals. Asian religions scholar Paul Kocot Nietupski examines how torma are used to facilitate interactions with both enlightened beings and demonic forces, and how they express local identity while building bonds between religious communities.

Key Terms

aniconic

An icon is a picture of a sacred figure, while an “aniconic” image does not picture such figure, a god or deity, but instead represents them through symbols. For example, the Buddha can be represented by a wheel, a tree, an empty throne, a parasol, or footprints.

cham

Cham is a type of ritual dance performed in Tibetan Buddhism, often at holidays like the new year or the Monlam Chenmo prayer festival. The cham dancers, who are usually monks, put on masks and perform the actions of the deities they portray. Often these dancers are understood to “become” the deities. The dances often have an exorcistic function and generally are performed for the benefit of an entire community.

karma

Hinduism and Buddhism both hold that actions (Skt. karma) have inevitable results which may take a shorter or longer time to occur. Mental, verbal, and physical actions all have positive or negative consequences and are considered karma. Depending on conditions, karma can manifest results either in this or future lives. Karma directly relates to the idea of reincarnation, and positive karma can also create religious merit and lead to a better rebirth, while negative actions, or karma, result in worse experiences in the present and future lives. Buddhists strive to achieve enlightenment to escape this cycle of karmic action and consequence.

Panchen Lama

The Panchen Lamas are an important tulku, or reincarnated lama lineage, in Tibet considered second in prestige within the Geluk tradition only to the Dalai Lamas. The Fifth Dalai Lama (1617–1682) declared that his tutor Lobzang Chokyi Gyeltsen (1570–1662) was the incarnation of Amitabha and granted him the title Panchen. Three “pre-incarnations” were identified, making Lobzang Chokyi Gyeltsen formally the fourth in the lineage. A special teacher-student relationship exists between the Dalai and Panchen lamas, when one passes away the other takes charge of identifying and educating the new incarnation. The traditional seat of the Panchen Lamas is Tashilhunpo Monastery in Shigatse.

Tormas, as they are known in Tibetan (bali in ), are ritual sculptures made of flour, butter, and decorative materials and are used in Tibetan, Indian, and other Asian religious traditions as conduits to a range of divinities. The most common  are made of roasted barley flour and butter—two important staples of the Himalayan diet—and are intended as offerings of food to deities (fig. 2). In addition, humans can participate in torma functions, for example in the  ransom torma (ludzong), in ritualized medicine (lutor), projecting or “throwing” a prayer, a request, or a compelling command to a , and in return receiving a substantive response from the deity (figs. 3 and 4). Tormas are intended to be attractive art objects and appetizing foods for communities of divinities and of humans. They are also intended to be effective tools for use in a broad range of functions, including protection, Buddhist insight, tantric rituals, for good luck on auspicious holidays, and for community needs in general. Torma rituals vary, from long, detailed liturgies to brief recitations.

Wide view of tiered arrangement of butter sculptures and votive offerings; deity statue under golden curtain in background
Fig. 2.

Aniconic torma butter sculptures; Wenfengsi, Lijiang, Yunnan Province, China; photograph by Karl Debreczeny, 2009

Video
Fig. 3.

Pathgate Theatre, "Torma-making," YouTube, March 15, 2007, 4:26, https://youtube.com/watch?v=a_BC8e6xJlk

Video
Fig. 4.

AldaEaton, "Yeshi Dorjee- Tibetan butter sculpture," YouTube, August 26, 2014, 7:31, https://youtube.com/watch?v=ghFIQJOaG5U

Practical Uses of Tormas

Torma offering rituals can be expressions of local identity and used to build bonds between religious communities. For instance, group belief in and worship of a bright blue torma of , a transcendent  and source of all elements of existence, can enhance regional community religious identity (fig. 1). Worship of Tibetan Buddhist iconic tormas of the famous eighteenth-century Tibetan Buddhist  scholar,  the Second Jamyang Zhepa (1728–1791), can enhance commitments to the regional political and religious institutions, in this case the Gelukpa Labrang  and its branch communities. In this respect the ostensibly religious tormas serve social and political purposes. Further, as with other art objects, one can recognize the sources of distinctively sculpted tormas and works of prominent artists from different regions. For example, in Amdo, one can see the differences between artworks made by Labrang artists and by those from nearby Sengge Shong. This recognition likewise generates a sense of community definition. 

Types of Torma

Tormas are often at the center of Tibetan Buddhist ritual practices and used to engage Buddhist and non-Buddhist deities, tantric protectors, , and historically prominent scholars. Local Tibetan deities include, among others, yul lha (regional deities), zhi dak (local lords),  (local tutelary deities), don (local spirits), gek (demons), and lu (, semidivine aquatic creatures). The deities often play specific roles in communities and homelands, and require specialized recognition and offerings, often communicated by tormas (sometimes of very large scale).

Iconic Tormas

There are accordingly many types of tormas, among them iconic tormas with a deity or historical figure carved, painted, or imagined. Iconic tormas often depict brightly colored Buddhist divinities or saints, and are used in a wide range of rituals. Works portraying Vajradhara (fig. 1) and the Second Jamyang Zhepa (fig. 5) are examples of iconic tormas.

The iconic torma for  (fig. 6) and details of the ritual process for invoking him are described in text excerpts from the “One Hundred Tormas” (Torma gya tsa), a relatively long torma liturgy composed by the Fourth Panchen Lama Lobzang Chokyi Gyeltsen (1570–1662). This document contextualizes tormas with ancient Buddhist teachings on dependent origination and goes on to assert that the fundamental mode of being of all elements of existence is . It includes a statement of the  commitment to the speedy attainment of Buddhist enlightenment by all living beings. The text provides a description and liturgy of an “offering torma” to Avalokiteshvara, for  and recitation (excerpts paraphrased in English as follow):

This torma is offered to appease the leader of demons, to appease spirits that afflict children, and others, nonhumans and powerful beings visible and invisible. It is offered to protectors of the teachings and to those who generate unchanging love, especially to those who eliminate negative and generate positive circumstances, to the one thousand eight hundred classes of demons, the three hundred and sixty devils, the fifteen ghosts above, in between, and below, the demons and elementals. This offering torma will satisfy and counteract disease, epidemic, famine, frost and hail, drought, and will bring mental and physical benefit to all living beings who have been our parents.

This torma purifies all of the retributive causes of rebirth—killing, capturing, beating, stealing, robbing, and all that lead one to bondage. Eliminating causes of rebirth, one will quickly attain the best goal, enlightenment.

Aniconic Tormas

 flour-and-butter tormas serve as receptacles and food for ephemeral deities invoked to receive and consume the torma offerings (figs. 7). The deities reciprocate by granting the wishes of the supplicants. In the image below (fig. 8), the topmost torma diagram is designated as white in color, on a white moon disk, both on a green vase, and both of these on a sun disk. The middle aniconic torma is a healing torma with a tantric song. The lower torma is a confessional instrument for beings in hell. The top is red in color and the base has four lotus petals.

Devotional implements in the form of cones decorated with white, green, orange, and pink discs and petals
Fig. 7

Aniconic flour and butter tormas; 2006; photograph by dharmaphotographs published under Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 Generic license

Three line drawings labeled with Tibetan text describing forms of flour and butter sculptures
Fig. 8

Jigme Lingpa (Tibetan, 1730–1798); Three Illustrations of Aniconic Tormas, from “Klong chen snying thig gi bla ma rig ’dzin ’dus pa’i gdang rol nyung ngu blo gsal mgul rgyan gtor ma’i dpe’u ris bcas dang pad gling gi dbyangs yig” [Chanting and musical notations for the performance of the bla ma rig ’dzin ’dus pa practice from the klon chen snying thig cycle of visions of ’jigs-med-gling-pa, with the illustrations of the gtor-ma cakes and chanting notations for the rituals]; late 18th century; image from Pema Kunkhyab, 1985, Buddhist Digital Resource Center (BDRC), https://library.bdrc.io/show/bdr:MW23624.

Iconic and aniconic tormas serve a broad range of purposes. The bright blue transcendent Buddha Vajradhara (fig. 1) identifies the community’s visionary origins, the crowned and richly ornamented Shakyamuni Buddha asserts the historical Buddha’s pedigree (fig. 9), the presence of the Palden Lhamo torma signals her protection of the Tibetan Buddhist Gelukpa order (fig. 10), Buddha  holds promise of longevity (fig. 11), and  cuts through ignorance (fig. 12). When the tormas are produced according to the standards for construction and invocation, with correct appearance and implementation, they are believed to be effective, functional devices. 

Colorful butter sculpture depicting Buddha seated underneath richly decorated canopy, flanked by attendants
Fig. 9

Shakyamuni, torma butter sculpture; Labrang Monastery, Amdo region, eastern Tibet (Gansu Province, China); 2014; flour, butter, natural pigments; height of figure approx. 12 in. (30.5 cm); photograph by Sandar Aung

Colorful butter sculpture depicting wrathful deity with blue skin and crown of skulls riding atop horse
Fig. 10

Palden Lhamo, torma butter sculpture; Labrang Monastery, Amdo region, eastern Tibet (Gansu Province, China); 2014; flour, butter, natural pigments; height of figure approx. 12 in. (30.5 cm); photograph by Sandar Aung

Butter sculpture depicting crowned Buddha with red skin, holding vase in hands folded in meditation
Fig. 11

Amitayus, torma butter sculpture; Labrang Monastery, Amdo region, eastern Tibet (Gansu Province, China); 2014; flour, butter, natural pigments; height of figure approx. 12 in. (30.5 cm); photograph by Sandar Aung

Colorful butter sculpture depicting Bodhisattva raising sword with left arm; holding right hand in mudra at chest
Fig. 12

Manjushri, torma butter sculpture; Labrang Monastery, Amdo region, eastern Tibet (Gansu Province, China); 2014; flour, butter, natural pigments; height of figure approx. 12 in. (30.5 cm); photograph by Sandar Aung

Torma Rituals

The torgyak (gtor rgyag) ritual is shown in a community procession following a  dance at Labrang Monastery in Amdo (fig. 13). The image shows a  and stylized skull on top of the conical zor weapon. The leader carries an aniconic butter-flour torma in front. The dance and torma ritual are performed (figs. 14 and 15). The ritual is intended to absorb and eliminate the negative forces accumulated in the preceding months. After the dance the community proceeds to the outer wall of the monastery, and the event culminates in the burning of the torma and the zor weapon.

Lamas carry tall, triangular sculpture in black, yellow, and red with stylized skull affixed to point
Fig. 13

Torgyak, a vajra and stylized skull on top of the conical zor weapon, aniconic butter-flour torma carried in front; Labrang Monastery, Amdo region, eastern Tibet (Gansu Province, China); procession after a cham dance; November 3, 2002; photograph by Paul Nietupski

Lamas and performers in sumptuous costumes gather around tall triangular implement topped by stylized skull
Fig. 14

Torgyak, a vajra and stylized skull on top of the conical zor weapon, aniconic butter-flour torma carried in front; Labrang Monastery, Amdo region, eastern Tibet (Gansu Province, China); November 3, 2002; photograph by Paul Nietupski

Video
Fig. 15.

KD Memory Clips, "Vajrakilaya Reversal Ritual (Gutor Puja) at New York Palyul Guru Lhakhang 2021," YouTube, February 15, 2021, 11:31, https://youtube.com/watch?v=LM-mbfSew6c

Another ritual figure from a New Year festival in about 1932 at Labrang Monastery is a ludzong, the lu ransom torma (fig. 16). This person and his costume express the function of a torma (dzong) and an effigy (lu), which absorbs all of the positive and negative influences on the monastery and community accumulated over the past year. The torma function is embodied here, and the figure is named as a torma. The figure circulates through the monastery and is eventually chased out, taking with him all of the year’s negativity.

Ransom medical therapy (lutor) is another torma function (fig. 17). In Paro, Bhutan, the officiant uses herbs, wool, a live chicken, foods, a bell, and a drum to perform a torma ritual,  invoking and compelling a malignant deity to leave a sick person, for instance a teenage boy with a respiratory disease.

Colorized lantern slide depicting seated man dressed in red tunic, white shawl, and feathered headdress
Fig. 16

Marion G. Griebenow (American, 1899–1972); Ludzong, “a lu ransom torma”; Labrang Monastery, Amdo region, eastern Tibet; ca. 1932; tinted glass lantern slide; height approx. 2 in. (5.1 cm); Griebenow Archive, Tibet House, New York

Person dressed in patterned textile and crown stands with implements before collection of devotional items
Fig. 17

Ritualized medicine (lutor); near Paro, Bhutan; 2014; herbs, wool, live chicken (foreground), foods, officiant with bell and drum; photograph by Paul Nietupski

Functions as a torma, with lu.

Contacts and communications between humans and deities are important parts of the Tibetan and Indian religious worldview. Tibetans and Indians share a world densely populated by deities of broad description, and the boundaries between human and deity are very porous. Tormas and ritual objects are vehicles for interaction between the two realms. In this vision humans and deities can interact with stylized torma gifts of foods often made of roasted barley flour and butter that compel deities to grant their wishes. Torma gifts can be iconic, with distinctive images of deities and humans who have places of prestige and power in the community legacy. Tormas can also be aniconic, exquisitely crafted with no anthropomorphic or divine shape of any kind. When accompanied by proper invocations, torma foods, and musical performances, deities are compelled to respond to human requests.

Footnotes
1

“The word bali occurs several times in the Rigveda and often later in the sense of tribute to a king or offering to a god
. . . . The attitude of the Vedic Indian to his gods was at least as compatible with tribute as with voluntary gifts.” 
Monier Monier-Williams, Sanskrit Dictionary. Accessed May 25, 2021. https://sanskritdictionary.com
/?iencoding=iast&q=bali&lang=sans&action=Search. For dyes and pigments used in tormas, see Jeff Watt, “Torma Offering Main Page,” HAR: Himalayan Art Resources, 2017, https://www.himalayanart.org/search/set.cfm?setID=1062&page=1.

2

See Frances Garrett, “Shaping the Illness of Hunger: A Culinary Aesthetics of Food and Healing in Tibet,” Asian Medicine 6, no. 1 (2010): 33–54.

3

See Tibetan and Himalayan Library, “"gtor Ma” Entry at THL Tibetan to English Translation Tool,” Tibetan and Himalayan Library, 2019, https://www.thlib.org/reference/dictionaries/tibetan-dictionary/translate.php. The entry for “gtor ma (torma)” lists tantric ceremonies, protection of the Buddhist Dharma, daily tormas, occasional tormas, and types mentioned by Künkhyen Tenpey Nyima: shrine torma (rten gtor), perpetual torma (rtag gtor), sadhana torma (sgrub gtor), offering torma (mchod gtor), mending torma (skang gtor), session torma (thun gtor), daily torma (rgyun gtor), captured torma (gta’ gtor), and food torma.

4

Jeff Watt, “Torma Offering Main Page,” HAR: Himalayan Art Resources, 2017, https://www.himalayanart.org/search/set.cfm?setID=1062&page=1.

5

For medical applications, see Frances Garrett, “Shaping the Illness of Hunger: A Culinary Aesthetics of Food and Healing in Tibet,” Asian Medicine 6, no. 1 (2010): 33–54.

6

For a concise statement of community bonding mechanisms, see Scott S. Wiltermuth and Chip Heath, “Synchrony and Cooperation,” Psychological Science 20, no. 1 (2009): 1–5.

7

Blo bzang chos kyi rgyal mtshan, “Gtor ma brgya rtsa [One hundred tormas],” BUDA: Buddhist Digital Archives by Buddhist Digital Resource Center (BDRC) (Beijing), accessed January 12, 2022, http://purl.bdrc.io/resource/MW3CN1676; Claudia Butler, “Torma: The Tibetan Ritual Cake,” Chö Yang (chos dbyangs): The Voice of Tibetan Religion and Culture 7 (1996): 38–52.

8

On dependent origination, the document says, “Ye dharmā hetuprabhavā hetuṃ teṣāṃ tathāgato hy avadat, teṣāṃ ca yo nirodha evaṃvādī mahāśramaṇaḥ” [The great ascetic explained that all elements of existence are causally produced and causally destroyed]. Jayarava, “Ye Dharmā Hetuprabhavā—Causation,” Visible Mantra Press, trans 2009, http://www.visiblemantra.org/dharma-hetuprabhava.html.

9

Blo bzang chos kyi rgyal mtshan, “Gtor ma brgya rtsa [One hundred tormas],” BUDA: Buddhist Digital Archives by Buddhist Digital Resource Center (BDRC) (Beijing), accessed January 12, 2022, http://purl.bdrc.io/resource/MW3CN1676, translation by Paul Nietupski.

10

The title of the song is “rdo rje mthol glu skangs gtor.

11

Rebecca L. Twist, “Images of the Crowned Buddha along the Silk Road: Iconography and Ideology,” Humanities 7, no. 4 (2018): 92, https://doi.org/10.3390/h7040092. 

Further Reading

Barnett, Robert. 2012. “Notes on Contemporary Ransom Rituals in Lhasa.” In Revisiting Rituals in a Changing Tibetan World, edited by Katia Buffetrille, 273–374. Leiden: Brill.

Eck, Diana L. 1998. Darśan: Seeing the Divine Image in India. 3rd ed. New York: Columbia University Press. 

Harrison, Paul. 1992. “Commemoration and Identification in Buddhānusmṛti.” In In the Mirror of Memory: Reflections on Mindfulness and Remembrance in Indian and Tibetan Buddhism, edited by Janet Gyatso, 215–338. Albany: SUNY. 

Citation

Paul Kocot Nietupski, “Tormas: Ritual Offerings Connecting Humans and Deities,” Project Himalayan Art, Rubin Museum of Art, 2023, http://rubinmuseum.org/projecthimalayanart/essays/tormas.

aniconic

An icon is a picture of a sacred figure, while an “aniconic” image does not picture such figure, a god or deity, but instead represents them through symbols. For example, the Buddha can be represented by a wheel, a tree, an empty throne, a parasol, or footprints.

cham

Language:
Tibetan
Alternate terms:
Tsam (Mongolian)

Cham is a type of ritual dance performed in Tibetan Buddhism, often at holidays like the new year or the Monlam Chenmo prayer festival. The cham dancers, who are usually monks, put on masks and perform the actions of the deities they portray. Often these dancers are understood to “become” the deities. The dances often have an exorcistic function and generally are performed for the benefit of an entire community.

karma

Language:
Sanskrit

Hinduism and Buddhism both hold that actions (Skt. karma) have inevitable results which may take a shorter or longer time to occur. Mental, verbal, and physical actions all have positive or negative consequences and are considered karma. Depending on conditions, karma can manifest results either in this or future lives. Karma directly relates to the idea of reincarnation, and positive karma can also create religious merit and lead to a better rebirth, while negative actions, or karma, result in worse experiences in the present and future lives. Buddhists strive to achieve enlightenment to escape this cycle of karmic action and consequence.

Panchen Lama

Language:
Tibetan

The Panchen Lamas are an important tulku, or reincarnated lama lineage, in Tibet considered second in prestige within the Geluk tradition only to the Dalai Lamas. The Fifth Dalai Lama (1617–1682) declared that his tutor Lobzang Chokyi Gyeltsen (1570–1662) was the incarnation of Amitabha and granted him the title Panchen. Three “pre-incarnations” were identified, making Lobzang Chokyi Gyeltsen formally the fourth in the lineage. A special teacher-student relationship exists between the Dalai and Panchen lamas, when one passes away the other takes charge of identifying and educating the new incarnation. The traditional seat of the Panchen Lamas is Tashilhunpo Monastery in Shigatse.

Download Essay